No. 273, Apr. 8- 14, 2004

SECCIÓN EN ESPAÑOL

CULTURE





To read an article, click on the headline.

Between Brilliance and Madness

Reality TV hits new low with
parade of The Ugly Ducklings





Between Brilliance and Madness

By najwa

“In the end, what it comes down to for me is that I desperately feel the need to connect with other folks like myself so I can validate my experiences and not feel so damn alone in the world, pass along the lessons I’ve learned to help make it easier for other people struggling like myself,” states the community page of the Icarus Project’s website.

The Icarus Project was created in the beginning of the 21st century by a group of people diagnosed in the contemporary language as Bipolar or Manic-Depressive. Unlike many traditional support groups,members of the Icarus Project are working to redefine their condition as “a dangerous gift to be cultivated and taken care of rather than as a disease or disorder needing to be ‘cured’ or ‘eliminated.’” Ashley McNamara and Sascha Altman DuBrul of the Icarus Project have taken the work of the Icarus Projet on the road. On Apr. 2, the Icarus Project road trip made a welcomed stop in Asheville, North Carolina.

In attendance at the meeting were about fifty people from Asheville. The experiences of the individuals at the meeting were a testament to the great need for such dialogues in our communities. Attendees of the presentation and discussion ranged from folks who were almost completely ignorant on the topic to several people who had been diagnosed and even institutionalized for Bipolar or Manic-Depressive “disorders.”

For nearly two hours, attendees and organizers of the event shared their stories of dealing with the social stigmas of and their personal battles with Bipolar Disorder and Manic-Depressive Disorder. The diversity of stories was a testament to the breadth of people struggling with these “disorders.” Although some were advocating for herbal and alternative remedies and others were in support of modern drugs, the whole group seemed to accept that different things work for different people. And despite any other differences, attendees all seemed to agree that one thing is necessary to break the myth of and support people struggling with Bipolar Disorder and Manic-Depression: communication.

That is exactly what The Icarus Project is doing. In addition to helping demystify the realities of Bipolar Disorder and Manic-Depressive Disorder by sharing their stories and initiating dialogues in different communities, The Icarus Project is also touring around to spread word of its increasingly popular website and new collection of essays.

To help others along in their own personal road trips, The Icarus Project has put together Navigating the Space Between Brilliance and Madness: A Reader and Roadmap of Bipolar Worlds.

Navigating the Space and www.theicarusproject.net are examples of how people are taking control of their lives and the definitions of those lives. As opposed to the traditional role of books and magazines on psychology, Navigating the Space is a compilation of essays and clips from emails written by people with Bipolar Disorder or Manic-Depressive Disorder or their allies. Rather than taking a sterile, medical approach to the topics, which range from Making Sense of Being Called Crazy in a Crazy World to Hitchhiking the Road to Recovery, this collection approaches the subject in a refreshingly personal and open manner. While it does not claim to have any answers, it certainly does make the reader think.

The Icarus Project website has been set up as a place for people struggling with Bipolar Disorder or Manic-Depressive Disorder to connect and build an alternative support network outside the mainstream culture. It certainly does just that. With its array of discussion rooms and its dedicated members, this website shows that people can take control of their lives. It has proven to be a great source of support, information, and guidance for many people throughout the country.

In its different projects, The Icarus Project seems to be living up to its goal of providing “a place that helps people like us feel less alienated, and allows us – both as individuals and as a community – to tap into the true potential that lies between brilliance and madness.” At least in one community, The Icarus Project has sparked a new dialogue.

Reality TV hits new low with parade of
The Ugly Ducklings

By Andrew Gumbel

Los Angeles, California, Apr. 4— By her own admission, Rachel L. from Washington state is plain and not exactly overflowing with self-esteem. “She’s a little average,” says her husband Mike, less than reassuringly, “but I’m more than happy with that.”

Right. Clearly he is not happy enough to have stopped Rachel signing up for US television’s latest reality show, which arguably pushes the genre to a new nadir of tastelessness and ethical questionability.

On The Swan, which to be shown on Rupert Murdoch’s Fox network on Apr. 17, women with spotty faces, buck teeth, stretch marks, double chins and flabby thighs — “ugly ducklings,” in the show’s parlance — undergo a rigorous process of transformation through psychotherapy, physical training, and head-to-toe cosmetic surgery. “Total facial reinvention,” one of the show’s specialist doctors calls his particular job.

And that’s not all. For three months after they go under the knife, they are not allowed to look in the mirror to see what they have become. Then, with barely a pause to take in their new selves — the so-called “reveal moment” — they are entered in a beauty contest against each other so their carefully resurrected self-esteem can be demolished in an every-girl-for-herself catfight.

This show has gotten even the most unshockable television critics wondering if they have now, finally, hit their limit. It is even a stretch for Fox, the network that thought up Celebrity Boxing (Tonya Harding punching it out with Paula Jones), The Chamber (humiliations falling just short of torture), and Who Wants To Marry a Multi-Millionaire? (svelte nurse from Los Angeles marries man she has only just clapped eyes on because the producers ask her to).

As Tim Goodman of the San Francisco Chronicle wrote last week: “Whenever a reality television series is so repulsive in its premise or execution that normally wise people believe that we, as a society, have hit bottom, there’s only one thing to say in response.... Wait for it. Something far worse is around the corner.”

Plastic surgery is becoming a trend in reality programming. An ABC show called Extreme Makeover kicked off the fad last year. And now MTV has I Want a Famous Face, in which young people have their bodies reworked so they can look like their favorite celebrity.

Source: Independent (UK)